Hard or soft: One
of
the great divides between British and continental motorhomes seems to be
in seating comfort. Many UK converters go for body hugging comfort with
relatively soft foams and lots of soft padding, perhaps including fancy
shapes to give added support under the knees for example. Nothing
in motorcaravans is ever straightforward so although immediately
appealing, this 'soft' approach does have its drawbacks particularly in
hot weather in Spain say, and when these same cushions are converted
into a flat, or not so flat bed. There's also the issue of
adequate support and insulation from the rigid base when travelling but
since rear seat belts are relatively new in British motorhomes this
hasn't been a big issue in the past. The other side of the coin of
course is the rather firm continental upholstery that really doesn't
lend itself to comfortable sprawling on cool British evenings or wet
days!
I should comment here that many of the dearer
vehicles are already fitted with good seating solutions while budget
models like our Camp Swing may not be quite so good. Designers
have to balance both cost and weight against comfort and local
preference so truly
luxurious
materials like latex foam are usually out of the question on both
counts. Anyway we thought our own Hymer upholstery tended towards
the over-firm and gave some thought to making changes to the rather
basic polyurethane foam fillings - this being a much cheaper solution
than trading up to a luxury class motorhome!
Improvement needed: It wasn't long before we'd established our criteria
for improvement. First we wanted a softer feel to all the
upholstery on the dinette and the side couch and possibly even the
over-cab bed. Second we wanted to maintain adequate travel support
for rear passengers especially bearing in mind the firm vehicle
springing. Third if possible we would like to improve the
thigh/under knee support but not at the expense of a flat bed.
Defining 'softer' turned out to be a two part process since foams have
two distinct characteristics, hardness and resilience. By
collecting and comparing samples we established that our Hymer foams
were both too hard and also rather 'dead'. It turns out that
resilient foams tend to be more expensive and slightly heavier so it
wasn't hard to work out why! We rejected latex foam for exactly
this reason, it would have trebled the cost and doubled the weight -
reducing our available payload in the process.
Foams: Small
quantities of cut foam are available from many local suppliers up and
down the country but we felt we would like to deal with companies with a
really good selection of grades and preferably with motorhome
experience. After all selecting foams for seating on a
(semi-)rigid base being bounced along on commercial vehicle springs at
60+ mph doesn't bear much comparison to your lounge sofa! We
contacted a number of web based suppliers but for us three stood out,
Foam for Comfort of Leeds and
Priory Upholstery of Christchurch and
SM Upholstery of Cardiff. We
eventually did most business with SM Upholstery because they were both
very helpful and very competitive on the grade we chose. I do
strongly recommend that you try out the grade you are interested in and
do try it on the same base as in your motorhome. The dearer grades
are more resilient and in my opinion are definitely needed when the base
is rigid.
Innovation:
The
standard Hymer dinette bed is made up using the two seat cushions plus
one wedge shaped back cushion plus a small infill cushion plus an
optional long extension cushion - not very satisfactory. It soon
dawned on us that we could get rid of the odd pieces in the bed if we
simply made up a third base cushion matching the other two - and then we
could also have different, softer and more comfortable grades for the
seat backs. Hymer make the upholstery covers removable so it was a
simple job to unzip them and get the measurements for SM who then made
up the foam blocks complete with Dacron wrap and stockinette covers,
shipped promptly to my door. The results are a great improvement
and worth every penny. For simplicity we decided to go for
one-piece single grade foam but it is also possible to make up foam
sandwiches. If I was doing this again I'd be tempted to try this
using a firm-ish base and softer top layer. For domestic upholstery
these sandwiches are usually symmetrical and reversible but could easily
be a graded stack of two or even three non-reversible grades in a
motorhome.
We also added a
mattress
overlay to the over-cab bed choosing one from
FFC, again one of the better non-latex
grades is the optimum choice. Although reducing head height
slightly the improvement in comfort has made this well worthwhile too.
As a final tweak I also ordered some stockinette covered recon foam
wedges to velcro under the seat cushions. These provide
under-knee support while sitting but are put to one side when the bed is
made up. When not in use they store conveniently on top of the
wall cupboards. I experimented with a similar wedge for the long
couch but this has proved to be something of a waste of time, it really
isn't needed there. Suppliers like SM & FFC will cover any extra
cushions for you or you can do your own in matching or sympathetic
fabrics to finish the job off.
I hope this personal story will help you make your
own decisions about your own circumstances but I will say, if thinking
about it - don't delay, do it, you'll not regret it!
|